Which guitar should I get?

i would go with the American Deluxe because it has a v-neck. If you are comfortable with a v-neck, then that is what you should get. Remember, before you buy it online, go to your local guitar center or music store and try them both out, see which one you like best. But, if you cannot, go with the American Deluxe. (if you buy the koa, their just juicing every last penny out of you, it doesnt sound much different.) I hope this helped.